Advocates for the use of AI in the classroom have long argued that the tech could supercharge learning, giving the current generation of students a major leg up as they get ready to enter a nearly unrecognizable work force.
But reality has long struggled to keep up with those lofty visions. Educators have watched in horror as students in the AI era struggle to read long documents, complete their homework without the use of a chatbot, or pass in-person exams. Meanwhile, early claims that tools like OpenAI’s ChatGPT could have positive impact on learning performance are being retracted wholesale.
In an intriguing new wrinkle for the debate, young students appear to be rejecting AI tutors outright. Scientists spent two years offering use of the Khan Academy’s Khanmigo generative AI tutor to students across 18 Tennessee middle schools, as detailed in a new paper. The tool was meant to be used during the school day, and was directed not to give up correct answers in order to slowly guide students through the learning process.
The results probably won’t be shocking to anyone familiar with rebellious 12-year-olds. In practice, the students mostly ignored the tool — and when they did use it, it wasn’t for anything to do with their schooling. Instead of using Khanmigo to seek help during their online lessons, most students sent the chatbot off-topic messages, messing with it to test its limits. Many also tried to coerce it into giving up correct answers.
